The origin of consciousness in the breakdown of the bicameral mind
Explore The origin of consciousness in the breakdown of the bicameral mind by Julian Jaynes: 134 Hacker News mentions from 106 participants in 2007-02-22–2026-11-01. Read original excerpts, compare opinions and save this book.
Share on XThe origin of consciousness in the breakdown of the bicameral mind
134 mentions · 106 participants · 52 recommenders
Book editionFrom the conversation
Latest 20 source recordsA mention is not an endorsement. Labels are automatically classified by the source. Follow the original discussion to verify the context.
This record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker News… very much like it: Julian James, 'The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind' (see [1]), which influenced Neal Stephenson's writing of Snow Crash. Scott Alexander wrote a critique of it beginning "Julian Jaynes’ The Origin Of Consciousness In The Breakdown Of The Bicameral Mind is a brilliant book, with only two minor flaws. First, that it purports to explains the origin of consciousness. And second, that it posits a breakdown of the bicameral mind. I think it’s possible to route around these flaws while keeping the thesis otherwise intact..." [2]. A response (which I have not yet read) can be found here [3]. [1] https://www.julianjaynes.org/about/about-jaynes-theory…
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker NewsThis record preserves its author, date and source link. Open HN to read the full context.
Read on Hacker News